Top 11 - 3/18/08 **SPOILERS**

Yeah....missed the beginnig of Amanda and Kristy

The order so far is

Amanda, Kristy, David A., Michael.

I haven't been wowed by anyone.

As you know, me no likey Archie

Brooke is wonderful. It was an interesting song choice, not her best performance, but her personality is just so awesome and it made me love her more

She's reminding me of someone more and more....I wish she could do one of her own songs.

I ended up missing the last part of the show...well the end of Syesha's performance and all of Chikezie and Ramiele. I did see him playing a harmonica!

My hubby needs to try to remember when NOT to call me I guess I"ll have to watch them on You Tube later lol

Amanda wasn't as good as last week heck I think only three contestants were better than last week. Kristy, Archuleta, and Castro. I think Brooke and Castro were the best of the night. The judges didn't care for either so I give them this
And Simon agreed with what I thought since last week, another Beatles night was not a good choice. Now I guess we'll find out what they're doing next week tomorrow.
Well Chikeze did a country thing and I think it worked for him. Not as good as last week but better than his first 3 weeks. Ramiele did a fast song finally but it wasn't very good. I think this night pretty much stunk but I did like Castro and Brooke. I'll review it more over at Idol Unofficial.

And i'll post the videos and watch it again in full before they send someone home

Pickler is on the show tonight

Oh by the way if you didn't see the end of Syesha's Simon said that he thought Brooke should've sang that song. I think Simon was thinking that if she did really well for a fourth week that she might win.

I actually didn't watch them yet, but i was thinking the same thing. I've been so busy today in RL My hubby is going out of town tomorrow for a week and a half and I'm depressed about it

Anyway...back to happy thoughts I saw the beginning of Syesha's performance and I thought Brooke should have sang that song. She would have done it so much better. IMO Syesha is forgettable.

I also think syesha is forgettable. I think Brooke would've done well with it but after singing Let It Be I think it wouldn't have seemed as good just because it was so good last week. I hope she picks a really good song for next week so she can amaze the judges again.

I'm hoping Ryan announces the theme so we can start thinking of awesome songs for her.

I think overall everyone was compared to their performance last week as it was basically the same theme. It was a really dumb idea. I will keep saying that

I just watched the really enjoyable group song. It was soooooo boring.